Please leave my friend Phil out of the ongoing Battle over the Alamo

There we were, sitting beside each other. Phil and I. I’m talking about Phil Collins. But I just call him Phil now. Because I sat beside him for about one minute. As you can tell this is leading to one of celebrities’ worst curses: people who don’t know them writing about them.

2013 post on this blog following that year’s San Antonio Conservation Society Publication Awards

Okay. I admit it. Phil and I scarcely could be called friends. But someone needs to rise to his defense.

In Forget the Alamo, authors Bryan Burrough, Chris Tomlinson and Jason Stanford lay bare major flaws of men many Texans have elevated to heroic heights for their roles at the Alamo. They also illuminate less-than-noble reasons Texians were revolting against Mexico, including the preservation of slavery. This has so angered some of Texas’ leaders that their rhetoric against the book has helped it skyrocket up the bestseller list.

I have no arguments against any of the above issues raised by the authors. In fact, for me, this 1837 advertisement from the Telegraph and Texas Register illustrates one of the saddest stories emerging from the Alamo. Joe survived the Battle of the Alamo. Should not his service to the new Republic of Texas while enslaved to William B. Travis have been enough to secure his freedom? All the others who fought in the Texas Revolution received generous bounties of land. All a white man needed to do was cross into this new country to obtain a land grant. But not Joe. Exactly a year after the Battle of the Alamo, he became a fugitive fleeing to attain his freedom.

The authors of Forget the Alamo devote page after page to present an extensive case for questioning the provenance of numerous major items in Phil Collins’ collection of Alamo memorabilia that the musician has donated to the State of Texas for display in a museum setting. They became so focused on my friend that they cannot resist one last jab in the final paragraph of the book: “If Phil Collins wants to ‘Remember the Alamo,’ he is welcome to do so in the privacy of his own home.”

It is not Phil Collins’ fault that Texans gloss over anything non-heroic in their past. Like many a youngster, Collins became obsessed with the mythological portrayal of Davy Crockett on television and in films. As an adult, he turned that childhood fascination into collecting all things Alamo: “Every self-respecting musician is obliged to cultivate a hobby to relieve the stresses of the rock star life.” This hobby helped the musician navigate through a dark period when severe nerve damage in his hands made the drumming he so loved almost impossible.

Yes, as the authors repeatedly point out, there were warning signals about the authenticity of some of the items Collins was purchasing. He mistakenly placed too much trust in the men in Texas who served as his finders. He took their word over those of other experts. How many collectors of art and artifacts have been swindled in the past? Blame the swindlers, not the trusting.

Donating his collection of all things Alamo to the Alamo was not Phil Collins’ idea. He was approached with a request. Texas politicians, now in charge of the Alamo, over-eager to milk the iconic status of the Alamo for their own ambitions to campaign for higher offices, jumped on it. They were more than willing to ignore the opinions of their own experts, including Bruce Winders, cautioning them about parts of the collection. Phil, they promised, give us the possessions you so prize and for which you paid fortunes; Texas will build a museum to house them. There was no due diligence. Blame the power-hungry politicians, not the generous donor.

None of the current controversy is Phil Collins’ battle. Leave him out of it. Ripping the blinders off the portrayal of Texas’ past is not Phil Collins’ responsibility. It is ours.

4 thoughts on “Please leave my friend Phil out of the ongoing Battle over the Alamo”

  1. I agree with this writer. How could any of this be blamed on Phil Collins? If blame should be placed anywhere it should be the people who fraudulently sold these items and the people who verified their authenticity. Why would you even mention the name of a kind hearted generous supporter who has nothing but the best interest of the Alamo? Shame on these people.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Amen, Sister Gayle! I’m delighted that Phil donated his extensive collection to San Antonio. Historians will be able to sift through what’s real and what’s not, and it will be a cautionary tale for all collectors. And may I just say how jealous I am that you sat next to Phil, even if it was brief! Love his music.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.